The Chicken Check: who leads and who lags?

Swiss retailers pride themselves on quality, accountability and responsibility; yet none have signed the European Chicken Commitment (ECC), a science-based framework designed to reduce the suffering of broiler chickens.

Over the past month, Sentience has published four reports that examine how the country’s largest retailers – Migros, Coop, Aldi, and Lidl – measure up against the ECC. Today, we bring those findings together in a single ranking: the Chicken Check 2025. Over 9735 emails have been sent to retailers, urging them to sign the ECC. The welfare of over 80 million chickens depends on what happens next…

Our rating of the retailers

Our rating of the retailers

What to remember:

  • Coop is leading, but it is not leading the way
  • Migros is in a powerful position, with unfulfilled potential
  • Lidl and Aldi both need transparency and continue to lag behind their European counterparts.

Discover the full report on retailers’ compliance with the ECC:

Higher standards on paper means little in practice

Swiss retailers present themselves as champions of quality and accountability; yet their refusal to sign the ECC tells another story. The ECC is the minimum science-based standard for broiler welfare, and it has already been adopted by dozens of companies across Europe.

Our Chicken Check reveals a clear pattern: there is progress on specific criteria such as legal compliance across the supply chain, or stocking density; but none of this matters when fast-growing breeds still represent 92 percent of chickens in Switzerland.

The path is clear, we are asking retailers to:

  • Stop hiding behind broad «Swiss-quality» claims whilst relying on fast-growing breeds; treating high-welfare progress as a niche label rather than a baseline
  • Continue enforcing existing Swiss-level standards and working with independent auditors; partnering with credible organisations such as STS and WWF
  • Start committing publicly to the ECC, with dated roadmaps and full transparency; phasing in slower-growing breeds, publish CAS-percentage data; and aligning with European peers who already signed the ECC

Why does breed selection matter?

These breeds are genetically engineered to reach slaughter weight in a matter of 30 days – their suffering is pre-programmed. Chickens often collapse under their own weight before their short lives end. Until retailers commit to phasing them out, higher standards on paper will mean little in practice.

To be continued

The first phase of this campaign is complete. Now that all the information has been released, the question is: how will they respond? Is a change on the horizon? The welfare of millions of chickens each year depends on what happens next…

Until the next phase, we’re counting on you to keep up the public pressure and continue sending emails to the major retailers.

No comments yet

guest

Similar articles

It is not a question of how, it is a question of when

It is not a question of how, it is a question of when

Coop: the final retailer in our “Chicken Check”. Improvements, transparency, labels,... all of this sounds great. But how well does Coop’s practices align with the European Chicken Commitment (ECC), a scientific framework designed to reduce the...

It is not a question of how, it is a question of when
Same Aldi, different standards across borders

Same Aldi, different standards across borders

After Migros and Lidl, Aldi steps into the spotlight. Does it live up to the European Chicken Commitment (ECC), the scientific framework designed to reduce the suffering of broiler chickens?...

Same Aldi, different standards across borders
Vague promises do not protect animals, transparency does

Vague promises do not protect animals, transparency does

After examining Migros last week, Sentience is now turning the spotlight on Lidl to assess how well its practices align with the European Chicken Commitment (ECC), a scientific framework designed to reduce the suffering of broiler chickens...

Vague promises do not protect animals, transparency does
When the market leader leads, millions of lives change

When the market leader leads, millions of lives change

Across Switzerland, retailers shape animal welfare outcomes at scale. With the “Chicken Check”, we assess how Swiss retailers measure up to the standards of the European Chicken Commitment (ECC). To date, no Swiss retailer has signed the ECC...

When the market leader leads, millions of lives change
Why Politics Must Extend Beyond Our Own Species

Why Politics Must Extend Beyond Our Own Species

Why do our laws, institutions and policies still revolve mostly around one species – our own?

Why Politics Must Extend Beyond Our Own Species
When Science Meets Policy: A Milestone for Animal Sentience

When Science Meets Policy: A Milestone for Animal Sentience

The LSE is launching a pioneering Centre for Animal Sentience, led by Prof. Jonathan Birch. At Sentience, we welcome this vital step—proof that science and policy must meet to put the concept of sentience at the heart of decision-making.

When Science Meets Policy: A Milestone for Animal Sentience
In 2025, we are letting the pigs out! 🐷

In 2025, we are letting the pigs out! 🐷

We are launching a new federal popular initiative demanding outdoor access for all animals in agriculture. This new initiative has the potential to shape the discourse in Switzerland for years to come.

In 2025, we are letting the pigs out! 🐷
Sonoma County’s Measure J: Echoes of Switzerland’s Factory Farming Vote

Sonoma County’s Measure J: Echoes of Switzerland’s Factory Farming Vote

Recent animal welfare initiatives in Sonoma County, CA, and Switzerland highlight the resilience of grassroots efforts in challenging entrenched interests and promoting more ethical standards.

Sonoma County’s Measure J: Echoes of Switzerland’s Factory Farming Vote